ICMR Case Studies and Management Resources

Asia's Largest Online Collection of Management Case Studies

Directory: Case Studies / Free Resources / Micro Case Studies / Business Ethics

Klaus Kleinfeld Quits Siemens AG: The Debate over Bribery Scandal

Email Alerts | Invite a Friend


On April 25, 2007, Klaus Kleinfeld (Kleinfeld), CEO, Siemens AG (Siemens), announced that he would step down from his post. The announcement came in the wake of a number of scandals that rocked Siemens over a short span of time.

Mixed reactions greeted Kleinfeld's exit. Some analysts felt that Kleinfeld should not have been replaced since he had been instrumental in turning Siemens around and bringing it back into profit.

Kleinfeld had often been dubbed as the Jack Welch of Germany, and his exit raised questions about the role of supervisory boards in the management of German companies.

Founded in 1897, Siemens was the largest engineering conglomerate in Europe and offered an array of products ranging from electronics, engineering equipment, telecommunications services, industrial automation, and power generation, to transportation.

Kleinfeld's decision to quit did not come as a surprise as the Siemens' board had been calling for his resignation for failing to trace the embezzlement of large company funds and payments made over several years. Since 2006, a series of bribery scandals at Siemens played a major role in tarnishing the image of the company.

In May 2007, a German court convicted two former managers of Siemens for diverting the company's money to bribe employees of Enel SpA (Enel), Italy's largest energy company. In late 2006, another scandal had surfaced in the telecommunications division of Siemens involving slush funds1 created to bribe foreign officials to secure contracts abroad.

In still another case, Siemens was accused by IG Metall, a dominant labor union in Germany, of having tried to bribe a small union called AUB to gain support for its policies. In October 2007, Siemens was indicted for paying more than US$ 29.13 million in bribes to officials of Nigeria, Russia, and Libya.2

According to a Beijing-based information consultancy, foreign companies such as Siemens, Carrefour SA, and IBM Corp. accounted for 64 percent of the 500,000 corruption cases investigated in China in the last ten years.3

Though the bribery scandals came to light during Kleinfeld's time, most of the payments were made when Henrich von Pierer (von Pierer) was the CEO of the company. Kleinfeld took over as the CEO of Siemens in 2005 from von Pierer, who held the job from 1992 till 2005.

During Kleinfeld's tenure, in addition to a major restructuring program, there was a crackdown on the employees engaging in illegal conduct. In 2006, the company hired outside legal experts and auditing firms to revamp its internal accounting and control systems.

Kleinfeld hoped that the investigations would lead to a total exposure of the wrong practices prevailing in the company and that proper measures would be taken to eliminate them.

Micro Case Studies Main Page Buy This Business Environment Case Study

Continued...


1] A slush fund is an auxiliary monetary account or a reserve fund. The term is commonly used in the context of corrupt dealings (such as bribery or graft) by governments, large corporations, or other bodies and individuals.

2] David Crawford, "Inside Bribery Probe of Siemens," www.online.wsj.com, December 28, 2007.

3]  "Chinese Media Questions Nonfeasance over those Involved in Lucent," www.english.peopledaily.com.cn, December 27, 2007.


Email Alerts | Invite a Friend

Google