The case discusses the IT outsourcing strategy of JP Morgan Chase, a leading financial services provider in the US. It explains how IT was managed in-house at JP Morgan before the bank’s merger with Chase Manhattan. It details the circumstances under which the decision to outsource IT management to IBM was taken and the expected benefits from this deal. The case then describes how the merger of JP Morgan Chase with Bank One led in the cancellation of the outsourcing contract. Finally, the rationale behind the cancellation of the contract and its impact on both the parties is also presented. This case highlights the problems associated with IT outsourcing and compares it with in-house IT management.
"We believe managing our own technology infrastructure is best for the long-term growth and success of our company as well as our shareholders. Our new capabilities will give us competitive advantage, accelerate innovation and enable us to become more streamlined and efficient."
- Austin A. Adams, CIO of JP Morgan Chase.
"The combined firm found itself with an abundance of IT assets. This decision was like other business decisions related to the merger."
- James Sciales, Spokesperson, IBM.
INTRODUCTION
In December 2002, JP Morgan Chase (Morgan), the second largest bank in the US in terms of net assets (Refer Exhibit I for the leading banks in the US in terms of net assets), signed a 7-year $5 billion outsourcing contract with IBM. The contract entailed the transfer of a majority of Morgan's IT services infrastructure including data centers, help desks and data and voice networks to IBM.
The deal also involved the transfer of 4,000 IT employees of Morgan to IBM. Morgan wanted to take advantage of IBM's On Demand expertise (Refer Exhibit II for a note on IBM's On Demand). The company began transferring its employees and IT assets to IBM in April 2003.
By January 2004, the transfer was complete and work began on consolidating data centers, upgrading hardware and setting up a common networking infrastructure, a task that was scheduled to take two years to complete.
In July 2004, Morgan merged with the Chicago-based Bank One to create a financial behemoth with combined assets of $1.1 trillion. Bank One was a strong player in the consumer banking business. The deal reduced Morgan's dependence on investment banking. Bank One was also adept at managing technology in-house. It had developed considerable expertise over the years in managing technology and integrating systems from acquired businesses.
Case Code ITSY047 Case Length 11 Pages Period 1999-2005 Organization JP Morgan Chase Pub Date 2005 Teaching Note Not Available Countries US Industry Financial Services
Issues
• Analyze the issues pertaining to technology management in a large financial services company.
• Understand how IT integration is achieved after a merger.
• Examine the reasons why organizations outsource IT infrastructure management and how the process is managed.
• Appreciate the advantages and disadvantages associated with outsourced and in-house management of technology infrastructure.
Keywords
JP-Morgan Chase,IT Outsourcing,Business Process Outsourcing,Outsourcing Problems,IBM On Demand Computing,IT-BusinessIntegration,Technology Management,Technology Procurement Project,IT Infrastructure Consolidation,Organizational Transformation,Offshoring,Technology Council,IT Strategy
Please note:
This case study was
compiled from published sources, and is intended to be used as a basis for
class discussion. It is not intended to illustrate either effective or
ineffective handling of a management situation. Nor is it a primary
information source.
To download this case (No. ITSY047)
click on the button below, and select the case from the list of available cases: