Case Studies and Management Resources
 Asia's Most Popular Collection of Management Case Studies

Case Studies | Case Study in Business, Management, Operations, Strategy, Case Studies

Quick Search


www ICMR


Search

 

'ALL OUT' - MARKETING A MOSQUITO REPELLANT

            

ICMR India ICMR India ICMR India ICMR India RSS Feed

INTRODUCTION

MAKING WAVES

 

THE GROWTH OF ALL OUT

The Arya brothers belonged to a Maharashtra-based family that was involved in the business of importing books. Reluctant to join the family business, the brothers shifted to Rajkot, Gujarat and joined a relative in making diesel engines for agricultural purposes. Before long, they became interested in the fast moving consumer goods business. Impressed by the success of a small mosquito repellant company in Rajkot, the brothers decided to venture into the business and set up KAPL.

KAPL decided to get the technology they needed to enter the market from Japanese manufacturers. Their decision was prompted by the fact that most of the modern mosquito repellants were developed in Japan. Having decided to launch mats, the brothers short-listed five Japanese companies and eventually zeroed in on Earth Chemical Co. Ltd. (Earth). Established in 1892, Earth was part of the $ 8 billion Otsuka Group of Japan. Earth manufactured and sold industrial chemicals, pharmaceuticals, consumer products, agricultural chemicals and health foods. After agreeing to a technical collaboration for mats, the Arya brothers happened to see a vaporizer being sold by Earth.

The product consisted of a heating unit and a small container of chemicals, which had to be periodically replaced. It was reportedly doing extremely well in the Japanese market, as it was much more effective than mats. (The strength of mats reportedly weakened considerably after a few hours - vaporizers on the other hand could function consistently throughout the night). However, Earth refused to transfer the technology for the manufacture of the vaporizer. After much lobbying and negotiations, a revenue sharing deal was finally signed, wherein KAPL agreed to invest in manufacturing the components of the product.

KAPL began developing certain key components for the product at its factory at Baddi in Himachal Pradesh in 1989. Some items such as moulds were imported from Japan. KAPL then hired a research agency to come up with a brand name for their product. The agency recommended the name 'Freedom.' 'Choo Mantar' (a Hindi phrase indicating the 'magical vanishing' of mosquitoes) was another possibility. However, KAPL rejected the agency's recommendations, and eventually settled on All Out, a name suggested by the youngest Arya brother, Naveen. Choo Mantar was dropped as it would not have made sense to non-Hindi speaking people and the brothers felt that All Out was better than Freedom.

To ensure that the packaging was of high quality, KAPL commissioned a well-known packaging unit in Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh. However, due to delays in the supply of packing material, KAPL was forced to delay the launch of All Out by about six months. The product was finally launched in April 1990 in Mumbai.

Sales were slow to pick up, as April was a lean month for the sales of mosquito repellants - mosquitoes being far more numerous during the rainy season.

KAPL hired Avenues, reportedly one of the best creative agencies in India, to handle the advertising for All Out. However, the company was not satisfied with the advertisements created by the agency, which had the baseline, 'All Out for modern mosquitoes.' Bimal said, "Six months down the line, we had holes in our pockets. They kept telling us to have patience as it takes time, but we lost patience."

The advertisement account was shifted to a bigger advertising firm, HTA, at the time of the product's launch in Delhi. HTA released a series of six advertisements, using humor to promote the product. However, the Arya brothers were not satisfied with HTA either. They felt that they were paying too much for the advertisements, without adequate results. Anil said, "Humorous and attention-grabbing they were, but the ads lost out on what the brand wanted to say."

KAPL then decided to handle the advertising for All Out on its own, surprising many industry watchers and drawing criticism from some ad agencies. However, the company surprised everybody with the launch of a campaign featuring an animated, jumping frog (actually an All Out vaporizer) eating mosquitoes, which proved to be immensely successful. The ad was based on similar advertisements made by Earth for the Japanese market. Later on, the advertisement included a man competing with All Out in a mosquito 'eating' competition and losing out. The short, funny advertisement cost KAPL just Rs 50,000 to make. Over the next few years, KAPL continued with the same advertisement, with only minor modifications to suit the launch of new promotion schemes.

KAPL advertised on videocassettes of Hindi movies in a big way - a move criticized by many advertising agencies, as these were believed to be 'downmarket.' Explaining the rationale behind this decision, Anil said, "We went for video cassettes as they got duplicated 20 times in the grey market. And it cost a fraction of what it takes to advertise on TV."

KAPL also made use of the evening news program on FM Radio and test cricket commentary on the state-owned All India Radio (AIR) to communicate in a cost-effective manner. On television, KAPL preferred to sponsor news programs rather than costly and more conventional soaps or game shows such as the hugely popular Kaun Banega Crorepati .

The company also pioneered the concept of sponsoring song/dance and fight sequences in movies on many satellite television channels (primarily) SitiCable and Doordarshan. All Out advertisements would appear before each song/dance and fight sequence in the movie. As Hindi movies typically featured 4-5 songs/dances, the viewers watched the All Out advertisement at least 4-5 times. This resulted in the brand attaining a very high mind-share among consumers. While All Out had an overall share of voice (SOV) of 31%, the nearest competitor GoodKnight had just 5% in 2000.

KAPL priced the heating unit of the All Out vaporizer fairly high, to cover the cost of the relatively expensive components purchased from Matsushita Electronics. However, reacting to market sentiment, the company lowered its price over the years, aided in part by increased in-house manufacturing of components. While All Out was priced at Rs 225 when it was launched, the price was reduced to Rs 135 for a cord model in 1994. In 1995, KAPL launched the 'Pluggy' (a small apparatus, in which the refill could be fitted and plugged in directly) for Rs 90. In 1996, a twin pack (offering the Pluggy and a cord model) was launched for Rs 135. In 1998, KAPL came out with a Rs 99 pack consisting of the Pluggy and a refill. The deal, called the 'deadly offer' was backed by heavy advertising.

By then, it was clear that the company was treating the vaporizer as a loss leader, to promote the sale of its refill containers. The 'deadly exchange scheme' launched in 1999, gave customers the chance to exchange a mat machine of any make for a Pluggy for just Rs 27. The response to this scheme was phenomenal with the company reportedly selling over half a million pieces in September 1999 alone.

Meanwhile, GSLL, which had launched its own vaporizer in 1996 under the GoodKnight brand, was struggling to maintain its market share in the segment after its initial success. GSLL launched a 60-night refill pack priced at Rs 63, against All Out's 45-night pack at Rs 54. However, the move did not prove to be very successful and GSLL had to support the launch by introducing promotion schemes. After KAPL's 'deadly exchange scheme,' GoodKnight's share decreased by 9.3% in volume terms between September 1999 and February 2000. GSLL then reduced the price of its vaporizer, but this too had little effect on sales.

KAPL's distribution network consisted of around 120 distributors across the country. Of the 900,000 outlets across the country, that sold repellants, KAPL was available in only 18%. As this was significantly lower than the 55% figure for R&C and 54% for GSSL, KAPL was working towards increasing its presence.

WHAT LIES AHEAD


[1] The One of the most successful programs on Indian television, Kaun Banega Crorepati was a quiz program aired on satellite television channel Star Plus. The advertising slots for the serial were reportedly sold at extremely high rates, as the program's viewership was very high

[2] Share of voice indicates the total percentage of mind-share that a brand possessed of the particular niche, market, or audience the company is targeting. The data is compiled by INTAM, a television audience measurement service of marketing research agency ORG-MARG.








Copyright © 2010 IBS Center for Management Research.
All rights reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | FAQ